Organizational Wellness

The Complete Guide to Manage Business Downsizing With Compassion and Strategy

Last Updated Mar 19, 2025

Time to read: 11 minutes

It's the call no leader wants to make: telling an employee their position has been eliminated. Yet, organizational restructuring has become an inevitable part of corporate life. Almost 200,000 workers were laid off in the tech industry alone in the United States, according to a 2023 Crunchbase report.

Once the decision has been made, difference between success and failure lies in how you manage the processes.

Even the healthiest organizations sometimes need to adjust their workforce to remain competitive. But while cost reduction might drive the initial downsizing decisions, the long-term success of these initiatives depends on maintaining employee trust, protecting operational capabilities, and preserving company culture throughout the transition.

What Is Downsizing?

Downsizing is a strategic reduction in an organization’s workforce to achieve specific business objectives. This process often involves laying off employees, consolidating departments, reducing operating costs, or scaling back on products or services. While it might just sound like a fancy word for layoffs, downsizing actually covers a variety of approaches designed to help organizations adapt to changing market conditions, improve efficiency, or address financial challenges.

This makes sense in certain market conditions that can push companies to downsize. For example, there was a two-point decrease in the job openings rate between September 2022 and September 2024, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. This points to a slowing down job market which can cause or result in downsizing.

You can think of business downsizing as a type of treatment for a medical condition. Some companies might be having a reaction to a slowing economy. Some might be having symptoms from a bloated workforce. And some might be having complications after a merger. Just as doctors prescribe different treatments for different conditions, companies may downsize for many strategic reasons.

For example, some companies downsize to address immediate challenges, like adapting to a slowing economy or managing costs after a merger. Others use it proactively to streamline operations, eliminate redundancies, or prepare for future market changes. In any case, the goal remains the same: creating a more sustainable organization that can thrive in changing conditions.

Types of Downsizing

Just as there are many different medications, there are also many different types of downsizing.

For example, a company scaling down operations after an industry change will need a different type of downsizing than a company that needs to streamline operations after a merger. Each type of downsizing has its own benefits and challenges, and the best choice depends on your company’s specific situation, timeline, and goals. These are some of the most common:

Layoffs: This is the most direct approach to workforce reduction. Layoffs involve terminating employees based on specific criteria, like time worked at the company or volume of sales. This method provides immediate cost savings but can significantly impact morale and company culture. Organizations typically use layoffs when they need to take drastic financial measures to save the company from bigger economic problems.
Natural attrition: This is when employees leave naturally through retirement or resignation. When a company is looking to downsize without layoffs, they may simply wait until employees choose to leave and then just not replace their jobs. This approach is gentler on company culture and morale. But it takes longer to achieve significant workforce reductions. It also gives organizations more flexibility to gradually restructure teams and redistribute work.
Early retirement programs: These programs offer incentives for older employees to retire before their planned date. They typically include enhanced retirement benefits, healthcare coverage bridges, or financial bonuses. While potentially expensive upfront, these programs can generate significant long-term savings and are generally viewed more positively by employees.
Voluntary severance: This is similar to early retirement but open to all employees. These packages offer incentives to leave the organization for any reason. This approach gives employees more control over their fate and can reduce the trauma of forced layoffs. However, organizations risk losing their top performers who might be more confident about finding new opportunities elsewhere.

Relevant Laws, Regulations, and Ethical Considerations

Staying compliant with all the relevant laws and regulations when downsizing can be tricky. Beyond just having to follow the letter of the law, organizations need to consider the ethical implications of their decisions and stay transparent throughout the process.

Even well-intentioned downsizing efforts can lead to significant challenges if not handled properly. Organizations must balance business needs with employee rights and set up mechanisms for all affected workers to be treated fairly.

WARN Act requirements: The Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification (WARN) Act asks workplaces to provide 60 days advance notice of mass layoffs or plant closing. This federal law applies to organizations with 100 or more full-time employees when layoffs affect 50 or more workers. Companies must also notify state and local authorities to give communities enough time to prepare for the economic impact.
Discrimination protections: All downsizing decisions must comply with anti-discrimination laws protecting workers based on age, race, gender, disability, and other protected characteristics. Organizations should document clear, objective criteria for how they decided who was selected to be terminated and must also review the impact on protected groups. You can audit your company’s downsizing decisions to identify potential discriminatory patterns before they become legal issues.
Severance requirements: While not legally required in most cases, severance packages can also help manage the downsizing’s impact. A well-structured severance package should include clear terms on payment amounts, continuation of benefits, and any conditions like non-compete agreements or release of claims.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Downsizing

Although downsizing isn't all gloom and doom, it also isn't all sunshine and rainbows. For example, cutting 100 jobs during a recession to save the other 9,900 jobs might be a good idea. But cutting jobs at the expense of client success might end up costing you the entire company.

It’s always important to weigh the biggest advantages and disadvantages of downsizing in business to make the best decision for your company.

Advantages

Downsizing carries a negative connotation. But it can also provide organizations with opportunities for positive transformation when handled correctly. Like pruning a tree to promote healthier growth, reducing your workforce strategically can help you eliminate inefficiencies and come out stronger.

The key is to focus on long-term sustainability rather than just short-term savings. Here are some of the biggest advantages of downsizing:

Reduced costs: Your company can enjoy immediate cost savings from payroll expenses and operational costs. Costs like office space, equipment, and supply costs generally go down with downsizing. Plus, smart downsizing can lead to streamlined processes that permanently lower overhead costs, even when companies are ready to grow again.
Increased efficiency: Downsizing often forces organizations to review their processes and eliminate any redundancies. Teams learn to work smarter with fewer resources, which can lead to improved productivity per employee. This efficiency push can reveal innovative solutions that benefit the organization in the long run.
Improved competitiveness: A leaner organization can respond more quickly to market changes and customer needs. Lower operating costs might allow companies to offer more competitive pricing or invest in innovation. Many organizations find they can better compete in their market after right-sizing their workforce.
Opportunity to restructure and refocus: Downsizing provides a natural opportunity to reshape your organization for future success. Companies can realign teams, flatten hierarchies, and create new departments focused on new priorities This is almost like an organizational reset that can lead to better communication and a more effective decision-making process.

Disadvantages

Even carefully planned downsizing carries significant risks that can impact both immediate operations and long-term success. Like removing blocks from a Jenga tower, eliminating positions can have unexpected consequences that destabilize the entire organization. Understanding the potential downsides can help you better prepare for and mitigate negative impacts. They include:

Loss of talent and knowledge: Beyond just losing headcount, organizations risk losing valuable institutional knowledge and key skills. Long-term employees carry with them critical information about company processes, relationships, and historical decisions that can’t be easily documented. The brain drain can affect productivity and customer relations across the board.
Decreased morale and productivity: Surviving employees often experience survivor’s guilt, which is a state of increased anxiety about future job security. In fact, about half of surviving employees go through this, according to the American Psychological Association. This causes productivity to drop as employees spend time worrying about their futures or searching for new jobs.
Damage to employer brandand reputation: How you handle downsizing can impact your employer brand for years to come. Poor execution can make future recruitment more difficult and affect relationships with customers and suppliers. Don’t forget that social media amplifies negative experiences, which means that even the public could change its perception of your company.
Potential legal risks: Beyond legal challenges, organizations might face higher unemployment insurance costs or workers’ compensation claims. Keep in mind that the actual cost of downsizing often exceeds initial projections.

Developing a Downsizing Strategy

Once you’ve determined downsizing is necessary, it’s time to do everything you can to execute it properly. Like performing surgery, you need a precise plan that minimizes damage while achieving your objectives.

Planning and Assessment

The foundation of a successful downsizing initiative lies in thorough planning and a careful assessment of your organization’s current state and future needs. Start by defining clear, measurable objectives for your downsizing initiative. These might include specific cost reduction targets, productivity improvements, or organizational restructuring goals.

Create objective criteria for making reduction decisions that align with both immediate needs and long-term strategic objectives.

Implementation

Successfully implementing downsizing initiatives requires a careful orchestration of many moving parts, like conducting a world-class symphony. It's a good idea to:

Create your timeline: Map out every step of the process, from initial announcements to final departures. Include buffer time for unexpected challenges to stay compliant with regulations.
Prepare leadership: Train managers and supervisors on how to handle difficult conversations and support their teams.
Plan offboarding logistics: Prepare severance paperwork, organize exit interviews, and coordinate with IT for system access changes. Consider timing and location to allow employees some grace.
Support transitions: Offer comprehensive outplacement services, including career counseling, resume writing assistance, and job search support.

Post-downsizing

The weeks and months following downsizing are super important for rebuilding organizational stability and employee trust. Remaining employees can struggle with increased workloads, survivors’ guilt, and anxiety about future cuts. Work with leaders to actively rebuild morale and keeping up with standard business practices.

Downsizing Best Practices

While no one dreams of leading a downsizing initiative, approaching it thoughtfully can minimize trauma and protect your organization’s long-term health. Here’s how to handle this challenging process with professionalism and care:

Transparent communication: Share as much information as possible about the reasons for downsizing and selection criteria. Regular updates help prevent rumor mills and maintain trust.
Compassionate execution: Treat every affected employee with dignity and respect. Conduct layoff conversations privately, allow time for processing, and provide clear next steps.
Future focus: Paint a clear picture of the organization’s path moving forward. Help remaining employees understand their role in future success and provide opportunities for growth.

Supporting Employees During Downsizing

Being told that you’re getting let go is one of the worst things any employee could ever hear. You can support the employees you’re making the difficult decision to part ways with by:

Maintaining open communication lines: Maintain regular, honest dialogue about changes and expectations. Create multiple channels for employees to ask questions and provide feedback, including anonymous options.
Offering support services: Provide outplacement services including career coaching, resume workshops, and job search assistance. You could even consider offering office space or resources for job hunting activities.
Providing fair compensation: Design severance packages that reflect employees’ contributions and tenure. You may even be able to extend benefits coverage to ease transition periods.
Giving them access to mental health resources: Acknowledge the emotional impact of downsizing on all employees. Provide access to counseling services through employee assistance programs and train managers to recognize the signs of stress and anxiety.

Alternatives to Downsizing

Before heading down the downsizing path, you’ll want to consider what other cost-reduction options might achieve your goals while preserving valuable talent and organizational knowledge. Some viable alternatives could be:

Hiring freeze: Pause non-essential hiring while maintaining flexibility for super important roles. You can review each open position to determine if they’re really necessary.
Salary reductions or freezes: Consider temporary salary reductions, starting with leadership to demonstrate shared sacrifice.
Retraining and redeployment: Invest in retraining programs that help employees transition to areas of growing demand within the organization.
Furloughs: Introduce temporary unpaid or partially paid leaves, allowing employees to return when business conditions improve while reducing immediate payroll expenses.

Handle Your Organization’s Downsizing Efforts Like a Pro

Downsizing is one of the most challenging situations an organization can face. Workforce reductions can have ripple effects on the company’s culture, productivity, and long-term success. Managing this process effectively is difficult, and taking the time to make the best of it will pay off.

A well-designed employee wellbeing program can help you deal with difficult times of organizational change. This is especially true if you’re concerned about the impact on surviving employees.

As revealed in Wellhub’s Return on Wellbeing 2024 report, 45% of hiring managers think that their wellbeing programs have a positive impact on retention. When employees feel supported in their overall wellbeing, they’re better equipped to handle hard transitions.

Speak with a Wellhub Wellbeing Specialist today to create a custom wellbeing plan for your organization.

Company healthcare costs drop by up to 35% with Wellhub*

See how we can help you reduce your healthcare spending.

Talk to a Wellbeing Specialist

[*] Based on proprietary research comparing healthcare costs of active Wellhub users to non-users.